Digeratimvp we have had this question for one of our clients before, here's an adapted version of it:
SELECT DISTINCT p.user_id
FROM posts p
JOIN discussions d ON p.discussion_id = d.id
WHERE d.id = 611671 AND p.user_id != d.user_id
ORDER BY RAND()
LIMIT 1;
replace d.id
with the discussion id, see your url, this discussion has id 36209
. Change LIMIT 1
if you need more winners (LIMIT 5
).
This will randomly pick one user randomly from all replying users, except the OP.
Thanks to @BartVB for pulling that out of the history/preparing this for your use.