Error during registration

luceos

HD3D I assume the selected default group does not exist..

HD3D

luceos Doesn't "Members" group exist by default?

This is what was selected for years and never had an issue until I moved to a new host

luceos

HD3D using default group to assign a user to Members is a fallback. I think it doesn't add anything if you use that extension with that group. Looking at the code it should in fact ignore attaching the group Members to the user; so I'm not sure why that's not happening for you unless you named an actual group Members. Can you post the value of the setting fof-default-group.group from the settings table in your database?

HD3D

luceos There's no fof-default-group.group

luceos

HD3D so that's probably what happens. Are you sure you are using the extension, because right now it doesn't do anything from what I can tell. You might want to remove it entirely.

IanM

HD3D

I just added some basic tests to the extension to check for this problem, but everything seems ok so far: https://github.com/FriendsOfFlarum/default-group/actions/runs/6402803526/job/17380077264

Your stack trace shows that the failure is coming from this line:

$defaultGroup = Group::findOrFail($this->settings->get('fof-default-group.group'));

but seeing as you do't have that setting in your database, the extension will fall back to it's default:

(new Extend\Settings())
        ->default('fof-default-group.group', 3),

3 is by default the Member group.

This leads me to believe that the problem lies in your groups table. Can you check that this table contains the member group with an id of 3?

IanM

HD3D what @luceos means here is does the settings table have the key fof-default-group.group, and what is it's value. Your screenshots are showing tables on your db...

HD3D

luceos so I guess extension has no effect anyways if I want new members to be assigned to "Members" group as it is flarum's default behavior and this extension is useful only if I want new members to be assigned to a custom group right?

IanM this is way above my knowledge and skills to understand, should I find this value within db or within this extension's files or somewhere?

Edit:

luceos

HD3D run this query:


select `value` from `settings` where `key` = "fof-default-group.group";

Your groups table isn't showing any other groups called Member, maybe the setting for default-group is wrong. That's why I asked.

I guess I need coffee @IanM xD

HD3D

luceos

HD3D yeah, I would disable default group unless there's something you need from it. It doesn't seem like you're using it anyway.