FriendsOfFlarum upload, the intelligent file attachment extension

The extension includes database columns to store the discussion or post relation, but this was never implemented, I those columns are always null.

There is this existing issue about it FriendsOfFlarum/upload154

clarkwinkelmann @luceos so in theory, it can be added ? I think this makes sense. Surely, if you intend to delete the post, you'd want the uploaded files gone too ?

[deleted] of course, in theory this can be added. But there's a lot of work remaining. Also all existing files will be orphans unless we write some system to parse back in time.

I'm not sure all platforms immediately delete files? For example Discord uploads can easily be used outside of Discord and I think they are not deleted imediately if you delete the post?

The biggest challenge is when adding files to a new discussion or post, because we need some way of temporarily having the file without relationship, then link them together when posted. Right now Upload does nothing to validate that the files you have in the post content were uploaded during the edit of that post. You could easily link other files already uploaded, and we'd need to decide what to do with those as well.

clarkwinkelmann Good comments. I understand completely. It's a nice to have rather than essential at this stage. I could simply remove the file in question manually.

Yalfoosh do you have a line about guzzlehttp/guzzle in your composer.json? Can you maybe share the output of composer why guzzlehttp/guzzle ?

What do you mean with the migrate issue? If you're coming from the Flagrow version, make sure you follow the update instructions. If you have an error message, please share it.

clarkwinkelmann do you have a line about guzzlehttp/guzzle in your composer.json?

Nope

clarkwinkelmann Can you maybe share the output of composer why guzzlehttp/guzzle ?

I have since fixed this, but these extensions don't even install it. It shouldn't ever be installed. By the way, I think it's because the guzzle that's packed with flarum is ^7.0. fof/upload wants ^6.0. This conflict shouldn't happen at all, it should work just fine! And it does usually.

And after a full reinstall (well, for the 3rd time) it does work. But I reproduced it on the 2nd reinstall and am suspecting it has something to do with the order of my installs.

clarkwinkelmann What do you mean with the migrate issue? If you're coming from the Flagrow version, make sure you follow the update instructions. If you have an error message, please share it.

I'm migrating my forum from 1 machine to another. Basically, upload can be installed on vanilla flarum, as expected. But it failed on me when I tried to do

composer require askvortsov/flarum-copy-links \
                 askvortsov/flarum-discussion-templates \
                 clarkwinkelmann/flarum-ext-circle-groups \
                 clarkwinkelmann/flarum-ext-emojionearea \
                 clarkwinkelmann/flarum-ext-group-invitation \
                 clarkwinkelmann/flarum-ext-who-read \
                 dem13n/nickname-changer \
                 fof/byobu \
                 fof/drafts \
                 fof/follow-tags \
                 fof/formatting \
                 fof/forum-statistics-widget \
                 fof/gamification \
                 fof/ignore-users \
                 fof/linguist \
                 fof/links \
                 fof/merge-discussions \
                 fof/polls \
                 fof/profile-image-crop \
                 fof/reactions \
                 fof/realtimedate \
                 fof/share-social \
                 fof/split \
                 fof/terms \
                 fof/upload \
                 fof/user-directory \
                 itnt/flarum-backtop \
                 noriods/auto-more \
                 reflar/cookie-consent \
                 studosi/lang-croatian \
                 studosi/mail-filter \
                 the-turk/flarum-edit-notifications \
                 the-turk/flarum-ext-fancybox \
                 the-turk/flarum-mathren \
                 zerosonesfun/flarum-ext-sm2

I'm unsure if it has to do with the ordering, but I'm too tired to reproduce it now that I've finally got my forum migrated. Also, I've followed this tutorial with a few modifications (public folder instead of assets, ex.). I might try tomorrow because I still didn't get the new gamification working.

Yalfoosh maybe it forces installation of guzzle 6 because of the php version, which one do you use?

OMG, I cant upgrade flagrow to fof.
But the composer tell me

Your requirements could not be resolved to an installable set of packages.

My php version is 7.3.18, so what wrong with it?

scvoet can you take a look at https://discuss.flarum.org/d/24684-can-only-install-one-of-guzzlehttpguzzle ? The problem isn't specific to this extension so I created that other thread with general instructions to solve it. Let me know if that solution actually work

How should I create a product for aws s3 from amazon site?

DursunCan we have instructions for setting up S3 in the wiki https://github.com/FriendsOfFlarum/upload/wiki/aws-s3

# composer require league/flysystem-aws-s3-v3
Do not run Composer as root/super user! See https://getcomposer.org/root for details
Using version ^1.0 for league/flysystem-aws-s3-v3
./composer.json has been updated
Loading composer repositories with package information
Updating dependencies (including require-dev)
Killed

http://prntscr.com/u07g5a : The bucket policy also writes a warning. https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/user-guide/add-bucket-policy.html i looked at this link. I tried it with the resource you have thrown. gave an access error warning.

http://prntscr.com/u07gg2 : How do I fill in the information here?

Jasper 同问，我也很需要！

wuyunfeng8 please write in English as per our community guidelines so everyone can understand

clarkwinkelmann OK,thanks!