FriendsOfFlarum OAuth

Having issues with GitHub (404 not found) and Google (400 missing request / invalid parameter: client_id)

Am I missing something?

logixworx I just enabled both of these on my test forum, as well as logging in here on discuss using GitHub, and don't see an issue with them at the moment.

There was an update released yesterday for the underlying GitHub provider, which resolves an issue obtaining the email address during registration thephpleague/oauth2-github20. It might be worth updating your dependencies just in case, but I don't think you'd be seeing a 404 due to this.

composer require fof/oauth -W

As for the Google 400 have you correctly entered the client_id in the extension settings for Google oauth?

Umutcan over the time since this extension was released there have been many requests for additional provider support. Including many different OAuth providers in the one package for convenience on the one hand is appealing, but at the same time could be considered bloat, as well as introducing additional complexity towards the maintenance of the extension.

As it stands, some of the most requested/popular auth providers are included directly in the extension. We've also made it possible improvements to allow additional providers to be added via seperate extensions to this extension.

For example these are just some of the extensions which add providers directly into fof/oauth:

• https://extiverse.com/extension/ianm/oauth-amazon
• https://extiverse.com/extension/blomstra/oauth-apple
• https://extiverse.com/extension/blomstra/oauth-slack
• https://extiverse.com/extension/ianm/oauth-line
• https://github.com/imorland/flarum-ext-oauth-microsoft

There could well be more, but these are the ones I'm personally aware of. Of course, other OAuth extensions exist too, that provide OAuth with X login, but don't reuse the fof/oauth framework. I would suggest that those extensions that do not do this consider refactoring, as their complexity can be greatly reduced by using the framework provided already, as well as keeping a uniform implementation for all auth providers.

Creating an auth extension for Twitch and Steam using the fof/oauth framework is pretty straight forward. As you say, an implemention for Steam already exists, but outside of the framework. Twitch could be created perhaps with a couple of hours work (going on a cursory look at the Twitch requirements).

Telegram on the other hand is also possible, but would require a little more time spent on developing a solution for Flarum.

Perhaps your suggestions here could be separated out into the three providers and created under the Proposals tag, perhaps even with a bounty to encourage their development?

Umutcan to further expand on my thinking, I've just created the Twitch OAuth extension to prove just how easy it is to use the fof/oauth framework

https://discuss.flarum.org/d/31955-login-with-twitch

Enjoy!

IanM It's great to see the extension topic while I'm creating a topic, thank you for creating this extension in such a short time.

Umutcan this is expected.

https://github.com/FriendsOfFlarum/oauth/blob/master/js/src/forum/index.js#L20

Google branding does not allow inline icon

IanM Got it, thank you for the reply.

1.3.0

Adds linked account status to your user profile page

• view at a glance which accounts you've signed into Flarum with
• Remove a link
• Connect additional accounts to your forum account

Updating

composer update fof/oauth
php flarum cache:clear

IanM

Thanks!!!

IanM

Great update!

The text is a little difficult to read on my forum - is there anyway to change this - or maybe the background colour?

Thanks!

I'm trying this extensions on flarum.cloud and it doesn't work with either Facebook or Google.
With Facebook, it redirects to FB and there's an "unknown error".
With Google, there's another error signaling a missing "client_id".

In my case is not working well, after make a successful login with Google, the redirect is going to https://peruguitar.com/auth/google awalys reapting the login form again.

please add ya.ru vk.com mail.ru

when a user tries to unlink their socials there is an error they are reciving.
"This provider does not belong to you."

how to solve this?

Umutcan maybe its something with flarum 1.7
@IanM can you check this?