luceos Can you share a screenshot of the user settings page that relates to the notification settings? Can you confirm, for a user that does not receive anything, that they have the right checks toggled?
luceos I notice only admins and mods are allowed to reply without approval. This might very likely be the cause of your issues 🤔 . Flarum prevents sending the notification because the post hasn't been approved and it might not be listening to the event once approved to send the notification in hindsight.. This needs further research.
meihuak luceos yes, maybe this is the key of the problem. but i use this setting, there is none spam post also, i think after we approve the post, they should get a notification
meihuak luceos there is one problem, when a user reply to a post of admins or mods, It also needs to be approved in order to show, but admins and mods can get a web notification
luceos meihuak a generic solution in flarum/approval would be best I think. For your use case for admins/mods you can probably create an extension yes.
meihuak luceos do you have a plan to solve this in v1.5? if you dont have a plan, i will pay someone to help me develop an extension.
luceos meihuak we don't have a solution for this yet. You can also commission fixes to core by the way, but as we've already entered QA and thus feature freeze, it won't be added to v1.5 anymore. Fixing this in core first would make a lot of sense as any extension might need to be updated when this fix is released.
luceos meihuak that depends on who is tackling this. You can also create a clearly defined Proposal for which we can open bounties. See our Guidelines about Bounties.
meihuak luceos i open a discuss, please check, is it ok? https://discuss.flarum.org/d/31570-get-web-notifications-for-posts-and-discussions-when-they-are-approved
